Every festive season brings a surge in returns. Last year, 65% of shoppers sent something back or exchanged a holiday purchase. That’s not a problem, it’s just the new normal for modern retail.
The real challenge? 60% of consumers say a complicated or frustrating returns process makes them unlikely to shop with a brand again. Half say they’d blacklist a retailer entirely after a single bad experience.
Holiday shopping is a whirlwind of guesswork, especially for gifts. People buy multiple sizes or styles, knowing some will go back. Recipients exchange what doesn’t fit or suit their taste. No surprises, just how consumers shop today.
But here’s the real test: How you handle those returns determines if a customer who spent ₦15,000 this December spends the same, or more, with you in January. Or disappears for good.
What Peak Season Returns Really Mean
Return rates during the holidays spike by an average of 17%, with 2024’s figures expected to reach $890 billionea, rly 17% of total retail sales flowing back. For apparel retailers, the reality is sharper: clothing tops the list for returns, mostly due to sizing issues. 60% of shoppers say it’s their most frequently returned category, with virtual try-ons still lagging behind in accuracy.
Today’s shoppers, especially younger generations, embrace “bracketing”: ordering several variations of a single item and sending unwanted options back. It’s not mischief; it’s a convenience they expect. Deny it and you hand these buyers to retailers who welcome returns without question.
The Real Risk of Poor Return Policies
Three-quarters of consumers care deeply about free returns. Two-thirds say a single negative experience is enough to switch brands. During the busiest shopping season, your returns process becomes a make-or-break decision point.
Complicated policies are customer repellants. Strict rules, slow processing, hidden fees, or insisting on original packaging all create friction, and lost sales. The retailers losing customers aren’t those handling more returns; they’re the ones making it hard, slow, or confusing.
How to Simplify Returns—and Create Advocates
Put your return policy front and center, on product descriptions, in carts, at checkout. Customers deserve clarity, not fine print.
Make initiating a return frictionless. Offer instant access to shipping labels, or better yet, QR codes that work at drop-off points without the need for a home printer. Process refunds quickly, ideally same day, always within 48 hours. The faster the refund, the more likely you’ll convert a complaint into future loyalty.
Don’t interrogate honest returners. When a customer requests a return inside your window, streamline the process. No need for lengthy explanations or debates about validity, just honor the return and move forward.
Protect Your Business Where It Matters
You’re not obliged to accept every return. Items damaged by customers, obvious fraud, or returns outside your stated window are reasonable exceptions.
With retail fraud still a significant challenge, it’s important to distinguish genuine customers from repeat abusers, without treating every shopper as a suspect.
Returns as a Differentiator
Many brands treat returns as a nuisance to minimize. Successful ones see them as an opportunity to showcase reliability. Make it so effortless that positive buzz around your returns policy drives up reviews and referrals.
For high-return categories like fashion, invest in fit guides, detailed measurements, or virtual try-on tools. Clear, honest product descriptions reduce uncertainty and naturally lower returns. In fact, 62% of shoppers say better product information would make them less likely to return.
Conflicting reviews or misleading photos drive up returns. Accurate and plentiful customer feedback, plus authentic product images, make a meaningful difference.
Sustainable Returns Matter More Than Ever
Almost half of shoppers now consider sustainability when making purchases, including returns. Every trip, every repackaged item, adds to the environmental footprint. Smart retailers close the loop by partnering with return drop-off locations for consolidated shipping, cutting down on emissions.
“Returnless refunds” are another option for low-value items: let customers keep or donate the product, saving both time and resources. Customers appreciate this transparency, even small improvements make a difference.
Technology: The Returns Edge
Real-time inventory systems that immediately identify returned stock avoid re-selling damaged goods.
Automated portals streamline return label creation and self-service, reducing call volumes. Analytics help spot products with chronic return reasons, vital data for future buying and listing decisions.
During the retail rush of December, robust returns tech is the difference between smooth sailing and a storm of angry customers.
Returns as a Loyalty Investment
When someone returns a product over the holidays and experiences a seamless process, something powerful happens: trust is built. The next time they shop, your store rises straight to the top of their list.
Returns aren’t business setbacks. They’re opportunities to prove your operational strength. Handle them with care, and you don’t just get your merchandise back, you gain a repeat customer.
Looking for logistics solutions that make returns as smooth as deliveries? A DHL Business Account gives you the control and flexibility to handle high-volume shipping both ways, so your return experience keeps customers coming back.
Share
